Reference Re an Act respecting First Nations, Inuit and Métis Children Youth and Families 2024 SCC 5

What does the Supreme Court decision mean for Métis government and citizens in Saskatchewan?

Recently, the Supreme Court of Canada released its decision in [Translated] Reference Re an Act respecting First Nations, Inuit and Métis Children Youth and Families 2024 SCC 5 (“the Decision”). The Court was tasked with answering the question: “is the Act respecting First Nations, Inuit and Métis children, Youth and Families (the “Act”) ultra vires (beyond the power of) the jurisdiction of the Parliament of Canada under the Constitution of Canada?

Departing from the conclusion of the Quebec Court of Appeal, which held that the reference question was constitutional, except for ss. 21 and 22(3), which were not, the Supreme Court concluded that the Act as a whole fall within Parliament’s exclusive legislative authority for First Nations, Inuit and Métis under section 91(24) of the Constitution Act, 1867.

Further, the Court found that the Act codified Parliament’s affirmation that section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982 includes a right of self-government in relation to child, youth and family services setting out Parliament’s understanding of specific section 35 rights. While the affirmations are not final determinations on the scope of section 35, they do have legal effect and bind the Crown’s future conduct. The Crown can no longer deny the existence of this right.

What does that mean for Canada?

The outcome of the Decision is an affirmation of what Canada committed to in 2016 when its government made a commitment internationally to support and implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People (“UNDRIP”) “without qualification”. The Court provided its most substantive discussion on UNDRIP to date, which bodes well for future judicial consideration of UNDRIP to inform the interpretation of section 35 and the implementation of its Articles.

The Court strongly endorsed the Act as a form of “legislative reconciliation”, referring to how the Act weaves the affirmation of inherent rights, mechanisms for the exercise of FIRST Nations, Inuit and Métis legislative authority, federal minimum national standards, and international minimum standards together. Importantly, the Decision also identified the Act does not purport to be the source of these rights but proceeds on the premise that these rights exist independently.

What does the Decision mean for the Métis Nation-Saskatchewan (“MN-S”)?

Saskatchewan will be impacted largely the same as every province or territory in the country. The federal government has recognized the MN-S as the Indigenous Governing Body (“IGB”) for the purposes of the Act for Saskatchewan. MN-S and its citizens will determine what their child welfare law, governance structure, policy and service systems will be – including how they will be developed and implemented. This includes what the pace, scope, and implementation of services will be over time.

In sum, the Decision will assist in providing agency to Indigenous, Inuit, and Métis people to control Child and Family Services for their communities. For Saskatchewan, MN-S assumes jurisdiction over their registered citizens and may seek to expand their role into other areas of justice in the future.

Contacting a Lawyer on this Subject

The above is for general information only, and not legal advice. Parties should always seek legal advice prior to taking action in specific situations.

 

About the Author

Kristian St. Onge is a Student at Law at Robertson Stromberg LLP. He received his Juris Doctor in 2023 and holds a Bachelor of Commerce degree in Finance with distinction from Edward’s School of Business at the University of Saskatchewan.

Related News and Articles

My Contractor Doesn’t Exist, Can I Sue?

It is common for contractors and other service providers to incorporate prior to starting a business. A corporation can provide a certain level of insulation from liability for the people who operate it, and in addition, allows for other advantages such as tax...

read more

Family Violence in Family Law

When asked to make a parenting order, courts will consider family violence as a factor relating to the child’s circumstances and, ultimately, their best interests. But what if the evidence is controverted? One consideration is credibility. In assessing the appropriate...

read more

Estate Litigation Update: Poole v Dailey, 2020 SKQB 226

I practise in the area of estate litigation and am often reminded of the importance of having a clearly drafted Will. A good recent example comes from the decision in Poole v Dailey, 2020 SKQB 226. The deceased had left his estate between his two children, Brian and...

read more

Students Join Tiffany Paulsen and Marinko Jelovic at USask Career Forum

willemien-kruger-lawyer-robertson-stromberg
willemien-kruger-lawyer-robertson-stromberg

University of Saskatchewan law students are invited to join Tiffany Paulsen and Marinko Jelovic at the USask Career Forum. Tiffany and Marinko will be discussing their careers at a session titled Life as a Litigator vs. Life as a Solicitor. The presentation takes place on January 13, 2024, at 9:40 am.

For more information and to register, click here.

Related News and Articles

Robertson Stromberg Well-Represented as Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers™ recognizes extraordinary lawyers in private practice through an exhaustive peer-review process. Today, Best Lawyers™, published the 14th Edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada and we are pleased to announce that twelve lawyers from the firm have been...

read more

Tiffany Paulsen Awarded CBA Distinguished Service Award

We are pleased to announce that Tiffany Paulsen, Q.C. has been awarded the Canadian Bar Association Distinguished Service Award for 2019. The Distinguished Service Award recognizes contributions and/or achievements by members of the Saskatchewan Branch to the legal...

read more

Tiffany Paulsen Receives Life Membership Award from SUMA

Congratulations to Tiffany Paulsen who has been awarded the 2018 Life Membership Award by the Saskatchewan Urban Municipalities Association (SUMA). This award is granted by the SUMA Board of Directors, and recognizes an individual whose career exemplifies commitment...

read more

Marinko Jelovic Joins Robertson Stromberg Partnership

Congratulations to Marinko Jelovic who became Robertson Stromberg's newest partner on January 1, 2019.  Marinko joined Robertson Stromberg as an articling student and, since his call to the bar in  2012, has been an important member of the corporate/commercial law...

read more

Twelve RS Lawyers named to 2019 Best Lawyers List

August 21, 2018 -- Robertson Stromberg LLP is pleased to announce that 12 lawyers have been included in the 2019 Edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada. Since it was first published in 1983, Best Lawyers™ has become universally regarded as the definitive guide to legal...

read more

Paulsen Presents at STLA/CBA Discussion on Women in Law

Tiffany Paulsen will be a member of the "esteemed panel of presenters" at the upcoming Dispelling the Myths about Women in Law panel discussion sponsored by the Saskatchewan Trial Lawyers Association and Canadian Bar Association, Saskatchewan Branch. Join Tiffany and...

read more

Tiffany Paulsen Turns to Journalism

After 16 years as city councillor, Tiffany Paulsen has decided not to run for re-election.  And beginning September 15, she will share her reflections on life after politics with the readership of the Saskatoon Star Phoenix.  Tiffany will contribute regular articles...

read more

Tiffany Paulsen honoured with Lexpert Zenith Award

Tiffany Paulsen has won a 2016 Lexpert® Zenith Award.  This award honours individuals and organizations for excellence in their careers and service to their practice areas, community, profession, law firms, and businesses in the field of Diversity and Inclusion....

read more

Tiffany Paulsen nominated for Women of Distinction Award

Partner Tiffany M. Paulsen has been nominated for this year's YWCA Women of Distinction Award in the Leadership, Management and Professions category. Tiffany is dedicated to her family law practice and is actively involved in several professional organizations. Her...

read more

Tiffany Paulsen named distinguished graduate

Tiffany Paulsen Q.C. was recently named one of the "100 distinguished graduates" at the University of Saskatchewan College of Law Centennial Celebrations.  The College of Law highlighted Tiffany's impressive litigation record before the Court of Queen's Bench, the...

read more

Tiffany Paulsen with baby Eden on the cover of “Bridges”

Today's issue of "Bridges", a local weekly newspaper published by the Star Pheonix features a story about RSP lawyer Tiffany Paulsen.  Tiffany is soon returning to RSP from a maternity leave.  Her other role, that of Saskatoon city councillor does not provide for time...

read more

Marinko Jelovic Presents at Canadian Bar Association (Sask) Mid-Winter Meeting

Join Marinko Jelovic at the CBA (Sask) Mid-Winter Meeting

Marinko Jelovic will be presenting at the Canadian Bar Association (Sask)’s Mid-Winter Meeting on January 25, 2024. As part of a panel entitled “Practice Management: How to Build and Maintain an Effective Corporate and Commercial Practice,” Marinko will be sharing his experience and insights on building a successful career in corporate and commercial law.

 

2024 Mid-Winter Meeting

Delta Regina | Regina, SK
 
To register, click here.

Related News and Articles

No Results Found

The page you requested could not be found. Try refining your search, or use the navigation above to locate the post.

James Steele Presents at Canadian Bar Association (Sask) Mid-Winter Meeting

Join James Steele at the Canadian Bar Association (Saskatchewan)’s Mid Winter Meeting in Regina on January 25, 2024. James will be addressing amendments to Part 16 of the King’s Bench Rules and their implication on estate administration.

 

2024 Mid-Winter Meeting

Delta Regina | Regina, SK
 
To register, click here.

Related News and Articles

Robertson Stromberg LLP listed as one of Canada’s Best Law Firms of 2024 by the Globe and Mail

Robertson Stromberg LLP has been listed as one of Canada’s Best Law Firms of 2024 by the Globe and Mail. The award list is based on over 10,000 recommendations collected from peers and clients. The final list recognizes only 200 firms in 31 different fields of law. The top law firms for each legal field were identified based on the number of recommendations they received from our survey participants.

Almost 25,000 lawyers, as well as in-house lawyers and legal executives working in legal departments of a company across Canada, were actively invited to take part in the survey, and Statista recorded more than 10,000 recommendations for law firms in the different fields of law.

Robertson Stromberg’s areas of distinction include Construction, Dispute Resolution (Litigation, Arbitration & Investigations), Restructuring & Insolvency.

To see the full listing of the Best Law Firms in Canada, click here.

Related News and Articles

James Steele Joins Robertson Stromberg LLP Partnership

Congratulations to James Steele who became Robertson Stromberg’s newest partner on January 1, 2023.  James joined Robertson Stromberg as an articling student and, since his call to the bar in 2015, has been an important member of the litigation department.James has...

read more

Congratulations to Jennifer D. Pereira, K.C. for receiving the Justice W. Frank Gerein Memorial Award

Established in 2017 by the Saskatchewan Trial Lawyers Association (STLA), the Justice W. Frank Gerein Memorial Award honours members of the profession who have made outstanding contributions to the legal community through involvement in voluntary and cause-related legal work; have demonstrated professional excellence in legal practice through examples of quality legal services, client relations, innovative programs; have promoted, encouraged or influenced students, graduates or practitioners; and, have demonstrated civility in their dealings with other counsel and the Bench. The 2023 recipient of the Justice W. Frank Gerein Memorial Award is Jennifer Pereira. For more information about the STLA and their honours, click here.

Related News and Articles

Webinar – Objections Cheat Sheet (CPD 292)

The ability to quickly object to an improper question at a questioning or trial is an important skill for any litigator to have. An Objections Cheat Sheet is meant to summarize the grounds and rationale for the most common objections and their accompanying exceptions.

read more

Area of Expertise